Goins, Writer

On Writing, Ideas, and Making a Difference

Seven Types of Blog Comments and How to Respond to Them

From Jeff: This is a guest post by Jeremy Myers. Jeremy is a prison chaplain, author, dad, and husband. You can follow his blog Till He Comes or connect with him on Twitter.

Every blogger loves comments. We communicators relish the responses our messages cause, and blogging allows this to happen instantaneously. But not all messages are always worth equal response. So how do you know?

If you have a blog, you will encounter all kinds of different people who leave comments on your blog.

Blog Comments

Seriously, who doesn’t love a good blog comment?

Here are seven types of blog comments and how to respond to them:

1. The Spammer

This commenter enters 50 links to “London Escorts” services and dog food sales. These comments are the easiest to respond to: Use Akismet and forget about them.

2. The Long-Winded

This person writes really, really long comments. 200 words is a long blog comment. 500 words is beyond long. 1000 words or more is epic. But you occasionally get those.

Generally, these comments are from people who are new to the blogging world and don’t know about the unspoken rule that comments should be short and sweet (50 words is pushing the comment length limit).

How to deal with them?

First, be gentle. Remember, these are generally (but not always) people who are new to the blogging world.

Second, congratulate them on their well-thought out comment. Tell them they raise good points and clearly have something to say. Invite them (nicely) to start their own blog to say it. If they already have a blog, tell them that their comment would make a great response post.

This is not only tactful, but wise, as it’s a great way to get an inbound link to your site.

3. The Nonsensical

You read their comment, and the first thing you say is, “Uhh. What?” The words form a sentence, but not one that makes any sense.

How do you respond to such comments? With exactly what went through your head: “Uhh. What?” Sometimes, they will return and clarify. Most often not, in which case, they might have actually been spammers that sneaked through Akismet.

4. The Non-Reader

This person clearly didn’t read anything past the title. Bloggers often write controversial titles in order to get people to read the post, but sometimes people respond to the title, rather than to the actual content.

All you can do is laugh, and tell them to read the post. The truth is, if they didn’t take the time to read it the first time, they probably won’t check back to see if you responded to their comment.

5. The Self-Promoter

This person has one agenda: to promote their own blog. They make some loose connection to your post with something they wrote on their blog, and then post a link to it.

How should you respond? Truthfully, I don’t mind this so much. Blogging requires a little self-promotion every now and then. There are subtle ways of promoting your blog besides posting a link inside a comment, but if that’s the way some roll, so be it.

I usually respond with a generic “Thanks for the link. I’ll check it out!” and then, I actually do, leaving a comment with a link to my post. Turnabout’s fair play.

6. The Generic

I don’t really understand these comments. The person will say something like “Interesting post! Thanks for writing it.”

Maybe this type of commenter is self-promoting through the link that is attached to their name, or maybe they are a non-reader, or maybe they just visit a thousand blogs a day and post the same comment, in which case they are a spammer.

I used to delete these generic comments, but found that many of them checked back on the post, saw their comment was deleted, and then sent me an email asking why. So I no longer do that.

Instead, the best way to respond to a generic comment is with a generic reply. “Thanks for reading!” is sufficient.

7. The Truly Interested

These are the best and deserve your full and careful attention. The comment is 100 words or less, and shows true interaction with the content of your post. They either add to the idea, or ask a thoughtful question.

You should respond in kind. Reward these commenters with a weekly or monthly “Top commenters” post, or a widget on the sidebar showing top commenters. They deserve to get some love from your blog for the comments they post.

These commenters drive your blog traffic. Treat them like the royalty they are. Visit their blogs, leave comments, and subscribe.

Other than these seven, what types of blog comments have you found, and how do you respond to them?

About Jeff Goins

I write books and help writers get their work out into the world. I am the best-selling author of four books, including The Art of Work. Each week, I send out a newsletter with free tips on writing and creativity.

Start Building Your Audience Today

Download my free eBook and learn exactly what I did to grow my blog from zero to 100,000 readers in 18 months.

In this book, I share everything I’ve learned from building a tribe and becoming a full-time writer — and how you can do the same.

Click here to download the free book now.

  • Thank you for sharing. it’s useful information, I think I need it. thanks!

    Stock Futures tips

  • USA NEWS

    Hi here USA NEWS,

    Excellent and very cool idea and the subject at the top of magnificence
    and I am happy to comment on this topic through which we address the
    idea of positive reaction
    http://usanewsheadlines.org/

  • Alex P

    Hi man, great one
    http://gzohar.co.il/

  • Suhani Sahani

    Very nice post here thanks for it I always like and search such topics and everything connected to them.
    Stock Trading Tips

  • Honey

    Thanks for posting this informative article. I haven’t any word to appreciate this post. http://www.ankitalal.com/

  • inspiring writings and I greatly admired what you have to say , I hope you continue to provide new ideas for us all and greetings success always for you !

    My blog : http://www.kubahmasjid123.com/

  • Vered n

    Thanks!
    Also a recomended site אדריכלים

  • You always provide information I can use. Thank you! http://showmethemuhnie.wordpress.com

  • it is a great post !

    http://www.itum-zion.co.il

  • Layla Summers

    Hi I read your post very carefully and I think you are right that a well written post should be at least a 100 words and should capture the essence of your blog, book or article. I think that people who have grown up with the idea of using computers are showing more responsibility towards writing posts that are thoughtful, do not have grammar mistakes and pertinent to the post.

  • mihandesigner
  • Great article of blog comments. Good contents hub for seo
    blog commenting tips. Thank for sharing.

  • Carlos Flavio Barreto F Souza

    Thanks for sharing those information.

    Carlos Flavio Barreto Ferreira de Souza
    CIO Flexdoc Tecnologia Brazil

    • fashionflatirons.com

      There are over 83,000 attorneys licensed to practice in the state of Florida.Every year, an average of 7,600 disciplinary cases are opened. Through a process of investigation and review within the Florida Bar and the Florida Supreme Court, accident law md

  • Shailvi Arora

    Mahima
    the world famous independent hyderabad escorts girl offering their elite
    hyderabad escorts service just in 10000 INR. Good looking hyderabad escorts
    girl for fun.http://mahimakapoor.co.in/

  • Shailvi Arora

    if you are disturb to daily
    work then you can fix your personal appointment with me, guaranteed your mind
    is sharp after using my Hyderabad escorts service.http://aviny.in/

    • fashionflatirons.com

      Many of the human beings do not rear pets at home but a minority of them around the world is very fond of them and treats them with all the luxuries that they treat their kids. It is not that they are unaware of the health issues that these pets can cause but yet, thor health care consulting

  • Shailvi Arora

    she is a point of your dating and set your life enjoyment,
    service offering Hyderabad escorts, escorts in Hyderabad and Independent
    Hyderabad escorts.http://www.shailviarora.com/

  • Shailvi Arora

    Purple Hyderabad escorts service is a famous for client satisfaction, you can connect our other service like as escorts in Hyderabad, Hyderabad escorts agency and etc.http://purplehyderabadescorts.co.in/

  • Great information and updates. I have use our all type.
    http://www.aperturastudios.com.au/

  • Great information and updates. Really i like it and everyday am visiting your site. Now Check out our website: http://www.l10stonewalls.com

  • Great information and updates. I like it and it help me to development very well (www.seacrossfishingmiami.com)

  • Crazy Bulk is 100% safe and legal steroids available in market.
    There are several products crazy bulk is offering in which dianabol, anavar,
    testosterone max, winstrol are some of the most popular products among
    bodybuilders. You can get your supply today at

    Crazy
    Bulk Reviews and Offers – Blog

    Buy Crazy Bulk 100% Safe and Legal Steroids

    ANADROLE (ANADROL): matttanner

    ISSUU – Anvarol (Anavar) P-Var by Matt Tanner

  • Dianabol (D-Bal)
    is a well recognized and considered to be the most powerful formula that is
    most generally known by the name as methandien, Methandrostenolone,
    metandienone. You can get your supply today at

    Buy
    Dianabol – 100% Authentic Source and Genuine Products


    D-BAL MAX™ – 100% Pure Body Building Dynamite

    D-BAL
    MAX™ – 100% Pure Body Building Dynamite

    100% Pure Body Building Dynamite


    Dianabol Max – Buy Dianabol Max

  • Crazy Mass is 100% safe and legal available in market. There are
    several products crazy Mass is offering in which Dianobal Elite Series, T-Bal
    75 Elite Series, testosterone max, winstrol are some of the most popular
    products among bodybuilders. You can get your supply today at

    Buy Crazy Mass 100% Safe and Legal
    Steroids for Sale

  • PhenQ is the Most Powerful Triple Action Weight Loss Supplement
    Pills. You can get your supply today at

    Phenq Reviews – A Miracle Weightloss Supplement

    PhenQ – FDA Approved Weight Loss Formula

  • Saiqa Imran Saiqa

    While people feel that escorts are those unfortunates who are involved throughout providing erectile services alone because of their customers, these are actually developing a wrong understanding about escorts. eyecandyentertainment

  • Saiqa Imran Saiqa

    Most workers that act on height should be provided training in the process safely. You’ll find inherent risks linked to working in height, in support of through training plus the provision in the appropriate protection equipment could you ensure that will injury as well as accident will never occur. constructionist

  • Motin Rahman

    This is a very nice post.
    you can see bloger c/a>

  • This article is 90% true..the other 10% needs to validate

  • Sakhi Kyal
  • Jarla Casey

    its perfect answer

    PhenQ 357 Discounts

  • ravindar ranjan

    its nice post

  • not sure with all of these comments here

    http://www.bintangbanua.com
    http://www.pompatenagasurya.com

  • Laurie Pawlik Kienlen

    My problem is that I have readers who ask for advice and help with their relationship problems, even though I repeatedly say I don’t give advice! I’m not comfortable ignoring them, but I can’t give advice. I haven’t figured out how to solve this problem.

  • Jarla Casey

    The ability, skills and command over the respective topic can easily be seen by this post , must give thanks to the author who created such a wonderful post

    Brestrogen, Breast Enlargement

  • test

    test comment

  • Sapna Patel

    http://www.bollywooddhamaal.website
    Bollywood News, Bollywood Gossips, Indian Actress and Actresses are the best place to know about Indian entertainers who can just reach all bollywood quality.
    Bollywood News, Bolloywood Gossips, Indian Actress, Indian Actresses, Bollywood Heros, Bollywood Heroiens
    Bollywood News, Bollywood Gossips, Indian Actress and Actresses are the best place to know about Indian entertainers who can just reach all bollywood quality.

  • Nice…..
    http://www.miamicharterboat.com
    We provides Luxury cruises and yachts for fishing trip in miami.
    Our charter is easily access from Miami Beach For more details and info visit: http://www.miamicharterboat.com
    or contact fishing@miamicharterboat.com

  • goyalamit

    Yeah, this blog is very informative for everyone also for those who are new and they can learn actual way of blog commenting. Best SEO Servives India

  • Hi!

    nice post thank you so much too sharing to us!

  • Alex Carroll

    Thanks for the best blog. it was very useful for me.keep sharing such ideas in the future as well Thanks for giving me the useful information. I think I need it!

    https://mysupplementreview.wordpress.com/2016/01/20/top-4-weight-loss-products-of-2015/

  • Alex Carroll

    https://mysupplementreview.wordpress.com/2016/01/20/phenq-natural-ingredient-for-a-successful-weight-loss/

    This is a very good post. Just wonderful. Truly, I am amazed at what informative things you’ve told us today Thanks a million for that.

  • Alex Carroll

    http://steroidproductreviews.blogspot.com/2016/01/comprehensive-answer-to-weight-loss.html

    Useful information shared..Iam very happy to read this article..thanks for giving us nice info.Fantastic walk-through.

  • Alex Carroll
  • Alex Carroll

    http://steroidproductreviews.blogspot.com/2015/12/4-tips-for-whole-figure-modification.html

    it was very useful for me.keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. Thanks for giving me the useful information.

  • Alex Carroll

    http://steroidproductreviews.blogspot.com/2015/10/incredible-crazy-mass-products-that.html

    Thanks for sharing excellent informations. Your site is very cool. I am impressed by the details that you have on this site

  • Alex Carroll

    I read it whole and going to share it with my social circules. I enjoyed your article and planning to rewrite it on my own blog.

    http://www.rippedlogger.com/2016/01/02/your-ultimate-fitness-plan-for-2016/

  • Alex Carroll
  • Pragati Jain

    Nice article

    for hacking tricks and tips http://www.hackingbank.com/

  • saba

    Very nice tutorial boss. The best tutorial ever. I am not scared of Frequency Separation anymore For photoshop tutorial visit…http://clippingphotoshop.com/

  • Jhon Osborn

    Aside from bookmarking your blog, I also want to receive updates from you

    Amazing Course Of Action For Novice Body Builders

  • Jennifer Mackey

    JaretGrossman.com is the best online resource for getting the best & exclusive personal and business consulting services for everyone including small and mid size businesses. Get the best coaching for business and leadership by Jaret Grossman today.

  • Blake Anderson

    Nice post..all points are so useful. http://jaretgrossman.com/

  • Dan Foggleman

    WOW I think its funny this post has comments that fall into all of the mentioned categories Mr Goins LOL I guess you are right. Anyone every heard of Top 10 Blog Comment Software [ http://affiliateswitchblade.com/blog/top-10-blog-comment-software/ ] – suppose to be free and find blog posts on first page of Google that allow comments. I can’t believe people still use the mass comment posting spam software like Blog Comment Demon etc.

  • jane smith

    I have not liked these cats since they became an internet “fad” a while back, but I couldn’t resist this one.

    Thanks for hosting this post today!

    frozen games unblocked games

  • Jennifer Mackey

    Nice post….Your comments also help build relationship with several influencers in
    your field once you start commenting impressively on other blogs. http://jaretgrossman.com/

  • Cool Ideas Dear !!! These all will be helpful for lot of people in all industries. Really Great 7 Ideas about commenting http://katrinaroy.co.in/

  • If you want escorts service in any High tack place like Delhi, Mumbai Or Gurgaon, We have House wife, Model girl, air hostess girl. you choose, what you want. if you want girl service then you click given city link. then find out city Mobile number Or whatsapp Number and rial pic. Mo. Number is :- 9811300267 And link is :-
    http://www.roshnirao.in/

  • MySkinny Plate

    Being a blogger I should know better, but I, too, am guilty of #2. I recently left a long winded comment on a blog but it was out of excitement for the topic. I will no longer be doing that, haha.

    I came here in search of how to properly respond to the comments my website gets and it resulted in me finding out what I do wrong. Love it!! I even responded to a comment left on my own website with a long winded response–crap, I’m still typing I need to stop. I guess you can tell I love to write/type. Stopping now. :-)

    http://www.myskinnyplate.com

    Great post!

  • WholeHouse CarpetCleaning

    Great post! Gave me a few good ideas. ..thanks!!

    http://www.wholehousecc.com

  • Michelle

    First, I would like to say I love your writing and blog topics as they teach and provide me with so much insight about engaging. I am still new to it and find your knowledge so valuable.

    Second, I wanted to add a little note about #6. As myself being one of those commenters in my early stage of reading blogs, I can attest that I was sincerely interesteded, but I just wasn’t skilled or comfortable in communicating within a community setting. So commenting my interest and appreciation was my best sincere attempt. I held sensativity in hoping the writer would positively receive my comment (so also would have felt rejected if my comment was deleted).

    Wonderful bloggers like yourself who would positively reply encouragered me to be more open and engaging in commenting. So know it’s helpful!

    A little insight to understanding a more introverted (unskilled) reader!

  • ChimeIn

    Great post. The ability to identify the 7 types of comments (and commenters) helps put things into perspective. They’re like personas, for commenters. Thanks again. We shared it on our Twitter.

  • bella

    Kunjungi Situs : masterkiu.com

    Deposit Minimal Rp 25.000

    Bank: Bca,Mandiri,Bri,Bni,Danamon

    Gabung sekarang juga!!!!….. Main Poker Dan Domino Online Uang Asli.hanya di masterkiu.com

    —————————————-­—————————————-­————————————-

    Next Info:

    Online Betting | Casino Online | Togel Online | Poker Online Terpercaya

    Kunjung juga Situs: 9ikanbet.com

    Deposit Minimal Rp 50.000, Bank: Bca,Mandiri,Bri,Bni,Danamon

    Daftar Di sini: 9ikanbet.com

    —————————————-­—————————————-­————————————-

    Jav and Korean Softcore Kunjungi

    Streaming Jav

    Salam Poker Mania……

  • Max Luker
  • Aashish Paliwal

    Check out : Pali101.com

  • Aashish Paliwal

    Check out – techlivelife.com

  • Nice post helful http://goo.gl/dKpDK2

  • another cool stuff :) on http://unblocked-weebly.com

  • Great article, we are like your tips,Gave me a few good ideas. thanks for sharing

  • FlashGames76

    Great stuff; check out my site at freeonlineflashgames76.weebly.com

  • Baber

    Great instruction. Check out my site: http://housingbeautytech.tumblr.com/

  • Home Blog
  • junaidkhattak

    Wow! thanks for writing about this topic. Visit http://www.allunblockedgames.net/ for wonderful Unblocked Games At School.

  • Sabki Saheli

    nisha roy
    great post even ! social media is so valuable to organization of all size it’s a real shame when some use it badly. this post will hopefully mean fewer bussinesses do the things you have highlighted.

    Thanks.
    http://anjna.in/

  • Thanks for sharing the information. It is very useful for my future.keep sharing. you can find us on.undergradtech here you can get all solutions related to Technology.

  • nice post keep updating thetechdon

  • Thanks for sharing the information. It is very useful for my future.keep sharing. you can find us on.ticotechie here you can get all solutions related to Technology.

  • dan pre

    hi jeff, Great tips on how to improve SEO. However I think the best way for
    businesses is to hire a professional SEO or SEM experts like you on
    monthly basis or someone like us at Create Website Servicehttp://www.buyadsenseac.com/

  • Mellysa Melody

    great post even ! social media is so valuable to organization of all size it’s a real shame when some use it badly. this post will hopefully mean fewer bussinesses do the things you have highlighted

    thx agen poker tanpa bot

  • Thanks for sharing the information & keep sharing.