Why Writing Can Be Dangerous

Every writer has an introverted streak in him. It’s natural. It’s necessary.

You cannot write (well) without spending some time alone.

As a result, every writer is an individualist. You can’t spend that much time in your own company and not think more in terms of self and less in terms of the community.

This is the beauty and danger of the writing life.

Dangerous Writing

Photo credit: Heath Brandon

Here’s why writing can be dangerous:

The invention of writing gave people the luxury of thinking apart from the tribe without the concern of those thoughts disappearing.

As reading and writing became available to more and more people, the community was no longer needed to retain teachings, traditions, or identity.

And because the tasks of reading and writing often encourage being alone, tribes and communities can be fractured as people spend greater amounts of time in private.

This isolation creates the conditions necessary for a strong sense of individualism to emerge. In pre-literate societies, a person’s identity is bound to the tribe; the notion of the individual has little importance.

However, the technology of writing, regardless of content, weakens and even destroys tribal bonds and profoundly amplifies the value of the individual.

-Shane Hipps, Flickering Pixels

Whoa.

So is writing evil or what?

Not quite.

But writing does create a sense of hyper-individualism — which can be tremendously good and, at the same time, potentially dangers.

Here are the double-edged advantages (and dangers) of writing:

Writing requires solitude

It’s a solitary practice. It’s done behind closed doors — early in the morning and late at night.

It’s hard to write and socialize. That’s why Twitter and Facebook can kill a writer’s productivity. It’s all about being alone.

And this is good, albeit lonely for those of us who aren’t born introverts. Like me. I have to be around people to get energized, but I know that I need to spend time alone to craft compelling copy.

It’s a challenge, but one that I must tackle. If I’m going to be a real writer.

Writing causes you to reflect

When you get alone, this is where brilliance happens.

You start pondering and dreaming and remembering. You look inwardly, examining your life and thoughts and deepest-held beliefs.

And you may question them. You may even dismiss them.

This is why writers are dangerous. This is why we must temper our questions with being grounded in some central truths that guide our life.

Because it is not always enough to question authority. You have to follow something bigger than yourself — you must commit yourself to an ideal, a perfect standard by which you measure your life.

Otherwise, you’re just another punk writer.

Writing allows you to communicate

Duh.

It allows you to dig into your brain and pull out those thoughts that are uniquely yours.

But here’s the danger: They’re not stories or traditions from the community or family. They’re your subjective experiences and notions. And they may be different from the accepted norms of your context.

Ideas can be dangerous. They launch revolutions and upset the status quo. They can spread propaganda (whether it’s true or not sometimes doesn’t matter).

But ideas can also heal dysfunctional systems and reconcile broken relationships. They can redeem social ills and bring sanity back to a world that’s lost its mind.

So writing isn’t all bad. Quite the contrary. Writing is an extremely powerful tool that has, many times over, changed the world.

Wield it with caution. And wield it well.

*Photo credit: Heath Brandon

About the Author

Jeff Goins

I help people tell better stories and make a difference in the world. I live in Tennessee with my wife and dog. Follow me on Twitter and Facebook.

  • Anonymous

    Thank you for this wise insight. It is a balance trying to harness that introvert part and create, and allow the extrovert part to mingle and socialize… I appreciate these words of wisdom, Jeff. Blessings in Christ.

  • http://www.myoneresolution.com/ Don McAllister

    Great thoughts here. I’m a born introvert too. Writing has challenges, and without balance can be downright dangerous and self-destructive. 

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      yep. too much of ourselves can’t be a good thing.

  • http://chriscornwell.org Chris Cornwell

    Real writers are compelled to share. A writer understands that writing is their voice and that they must share in order to re-engage in community or re-engage with the tribe. Any creative struggles with this. Creativity begins inward, but it’s what you do with it that reflects your heart towards other people.

    Love the “bridge” section of reflection, how we must submit to something bigger than ourselves.

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      well said, chris. you’ve shared some gems here.

      • http://chriscornwell.org Chris Cornwell

        thanks Jeff!

  • http://twitter.com/jhughes42071 John Hughes

    I find that some of the most compelling writers are those that participate in life.  Without interaction the true ability to tell a dynamic store becomes incredibly difficult.  I agree that once the process begins, solitude is probably the only way to finish a task but without a balance of contact with the outside world your writing can become so disconnected from reality that you will lose your voice and foundations in reality.  I think one of the greater problems with writing is that modern blogger/writers have deemed that participating in society includes facebook/twitter and never are forced to remove themselves from their comfort zone.  I’d say that some of the best writing I have ever produced is a direct result of some outside interaction.

    • http://thewritepractice.com Joe Bunting

      Writing for the tribe about the tribe while being inspired by the tribe. I like that.

      • http://www.tnealtarver.wordpress.com TNeal

        Good, concise statement.

    • http://www.tnealtarver.wordpress.com TNeal

      John, you make an excellent point. Writing devoid of community tends to dry up the creative process. I cycle with a friend on Wednesday mornings (which happened to be today) and we have an hour plus of conversation on a bike trail. By the time I return home, I’ve got ideas and new thoughts bouncing around in my head. I know reading also stimulates new ways of thinking as we deal with concepts someone else offers through his or her writing. But at some point, you have to connect with others before you write in order to connect with them when you write.–Tom

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      i have found the same.

  • http://somewiseguy.com ThatGuyKC

    My writing falls victim to distraction on a daily basis. I’m not a natural introvert, but I do my best writing when alone as well (and complete silence or white noise seems to help). I think there is truth to the phrase “the pen is mightier than the sword” and I agree that it should be wielded with caution. There are enough punk writers already.

    Great post! (I know that’s a copout comment, but it doesn’t make it not true)

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      i think most of us do. writing is more often than not a solitary work.

  • http://robrash.us Rob Rash

    Words can be a very powerful tool. They can be used to encourage and build each other up… or they can be a dangerous weapon that can literally destroy people. It’s a wonderful thing to write and express ideas, thoughts, and feelings, but like you said Jeff, ‘Wield it with caution!’

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      indeed.

  • Anonymous

    So much here–being grounded in central truths that guide our lives, wielding our words with caution, and well–powerful guard rails for practicing our craft.

  • http://www.jeffrandleman.com Jeff Randleman

    While I’ve trained myself to be a people person, I am naturally an introvery.  So a writing environment comes a bit more easily for me.  I still struggle with creativity and wording, but that’s another issue completely. 

  • http://twitter.com/kylajoyful Kyla Cofer

    This is a great encouragement to me, today. Just last night, I was thinking about how I’ve become more introverted as I’ve worked in a job that offers time and space for thought and reflection. That space directly affects how much I write.  I absolutely believe that words have power, and need to be used with caution. I also believe that because they have power, wise words must be used boldly.  I miss my extroverted self, but I really like the writing that comes from solitude. Hopefully I’ll find a balance between them both.

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      i hope you do. and i hope i am able to do the same.

  • http://alyssasantos.com/ Alyssa Santos

    Isn’t writing like anything else — it demands of us balance. We are to balance solitude with fellowship, syntax with evangelism, introspection with compassion for others — this balance makes us better writers. Btw, I shared the manifesto with my writer’s group last night and we had a great time talking over our favorite parts. The idea of “be generous” resonated with the group and we had a lot of ideas of how writing for the love of writing can be a generous act. They are all “manifesto-ing” until we meet again. It will be fun to see what their individual proclamations say. Thank you, and I mean that.

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      you’re right, alyssa. it’s all about balance.

      and THANK YOU for sharing the manifesto with your group. that’s amazing, and I am so honored. would love to see what they come up with!

  • http://thewholedangthing.wordpress.com Ben Emerson

    A) I love Shane Hipps’ thoughts on technology and media. Brilliant.
    B) I think we are more affected by our communities than we realize. We may write by ourselves, but we carry the culture, traditions, ideas, assumptions, and outlook of our communities with us.

    I think writing removes the shared experience of creating and experiencing art. People look at a painting together. People rarely do that with a book.

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      thanks, ben. that quote inspired this whole post.

  • http://shewritesandrights.blogspot.com Bethany Suckrow

    This post makes me think of this quote from Writing Down the Bones by Natalie Goldberg (excellent book for writers, by the way): “You can’t straighten up during writing and then hunch back down when you let go of the pen.  Writing can teach us the dignity of speaking the truth, and it spreads out from the page into all of our life, and it should.  Otherwise, there is too much of a schism between who we are as writers and how we live our daily lives.  That is the challenge: to let writing teach us about life and life about writing.  Let it flow back and forth.”

    • Caitlin Hennessy

      This is one of my favorite books on writing. My social justice teacher in college used this in the classroom all the time.

  • http://www.tnealtarver.wordpress.com TNeal

    As an extrovert in a cubicle (i.e. writing), I find I write best in a public place (restaurant, library, etc.). I appreciate knowing, Jeff, that you deal with that issue as well. Our written words don’t have the context of instant conversation so the feedback returns to us in bits and pieces. I like the thoughts you stir up as I read your article. I appreciate the give-and-take of a blog thanks to this marvelous concept called “Add New Comment.” Thanks–Tom

  • Majid Ali

    Please for Christ sake help this poor boy from Haiti
    I have made a blog at blogger.com Since i have added a google adsense in the blog but haven’t made a penny with this. I need your help and support to help me make some money to PAY MY Tuition Fees.

    What you have to do is follow these simple steps

    1.go to Google.com and search “Kwotz-Golden Words of Life”
    2.then visit my blog from the the search results.
    3.Remain on the page i.e Kwotz for one minute or so and do some random surfing
    4. click ONE of the ads that appeals to you from AdChoices and visit there.
    5.remain on that page for one minute or so and do some random surfing.
    and that’s it.

    Note:You MUST visit my blog from Google.com. Only ONE click is asked and nothing else
    I will be very grateful to you.

  • http://www.jamiesrabbits.com Jamie

    I think I’m a punk writer. I know at the very least I’m not focused.

    Exhibit A: When I saw your photo credit on this post, I stopped reading and opened iTunes to pull up “Leaving Eden” by Brandon Heath. Great album.

    ADD may be my greatest danger.

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      hmmm… that DOES sound dangerous. :)

  • Pingback: Top Picks Thursday 8-11-2011 « The Author Chronicles

  • http://www.surpasscircumstance.blogspot.com Shelly Miller

    Jeff, this post resonates with me.  I am also an extrovert who has learned how to balance engaging with the world and writing in solitude.  Much to my surprise, I have been delighted that what I write in my blog has actually provided opportunites to develop relationships with people that want to continue the conversation.  Your blog is like a warm blanket on a cold day for a writer. Thanks!

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      you’re welcome, shelly. good to know there are other kindred spirits out there!

  • http://www.FluentBrain.com Matt Tanguay

    I wonder what the correlation (or causality) is between writing and leadership. Does writing make you a better leader?

    In any case, great article!

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      maybe not. but writing requires thought. and thinking probably does.

  • Caitlin Hennessy

    I like dangerous writing. I think for the most part we could use a little more danger in  writing.  This might be why I love reading books that are banned or people think should be banned.  I am just that girl you tell me I can’t do something or not to read something and I will read it and decide on my own. Although this may be more the result of being an adult child of pretty well educated hippies so as much as I love the good music, good writing, I also love a good sit in, protest or freedom ride. 

    • http://goinswriter.com/ Jeff Goins

      me, too.